Dzire Tour S CNG vs Hyundai Prime SD CNG
A taxi-owner comparison focused on purchase setup, manufacturer-claimed CNG mileage, fuel economics, support and commercial-use practicality.
Tour S CNG
Prime SD CNG
Quick taxi comparison
Specifications and reference prices below use current manufacturer information. Claimed mileage is not the same as real-world taxi mileage.
| Taxi factor | Tour S | Prime SD |
|---|---|---|
| Vehicle | Maruti Suzuki Tour S CNG | Hyundai Prime SD 1.2 MT CNG |
| Current manufacturer ex-showroom reference | ₹7,09,800* | ₹6,95,600* |
| Passenger segment | Commercial sedan | Commercial sedan |
| Engine | 1197 cc | 1197 cc |
| Transmission | 5-speed manual | 5-speed manual |
| Manufacturer-claimed CNG mileage | 34.30 km/kg | 28.40 km/kg |
| CNG power | 51.3 kW / 69.75 PS @ 5700 rpm | 50.5 kW / 69 PS @ 6000 rpm |
| CNG torque | 101.8 Nm | 95.2 Nm |
| Safety | 6 airbags; ABS with EBD and Brake Assist | 6 airbags; ABS with EBD |
| Passenger comfort | Front & rear power windows; digital AC | Front & rear power windows; rear AC vent |
| Commercial-use equipment | Factory S-CNG commercial model; speed limiting function | Factory CNG; speed limiter; VLTD with panic buttons |
| Commercial-use focus | High-running city, airport and fleet duty | City, airport and corporate sedan duty |
Commercial acquisition cost comparison
Select a state to see available local reference data. We show figures only where we have suitable evidence rather than copying one state's charges across India.
Maruti Suzuki Tour S CNG
Hyundai Prime SD CNG
Fuel Cost Based on Manufacturer-Claimed Mileage
Enter your local CNG price and monthly running. The calculator uses 34.30 km/kg for Tour S CNG and 28.40 km/kg for Prime SD CNG, both manufacturer-claimed figures.
Editable — enter the CNG price in your city.
Manufacturer-claimed CNG mileage; actual taxi mileage can differ.
Manufacturer-claimed CNG mileage; actual taxi mileage can differ.
Use a preset or enter your actual monthly taxi running.
Quick monthly running comparison
| Monthly running | Tour S CNG | Prime SD CNG | Tour S fuel saving |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3,000 km 36,000 km/year | ₹7,872/month 87.5 kg CNG | ₹9,507/month 105.6 kg CNG | ₹1,635/month ₹19,624/year |
| 5,000 km 60,000 km/year | ₹13,120/month 145.8 kg CNG | ₹15,845/month 176.1 kg CNG | ₹2,726/month ₹32,706/year |
| 7,000 km 84,000 km/year | ₹18,367/month 204.1 kg CNG | ₹22,183/month 246.5 kg CNG | ₹3,816/month ₹45,789/year |
Fuel cost up to 2,00,000 km
This compares fuel expense by total vehicle kilometres, independent of how many months it takes you to reach the milestone.
| Total running | Tour S fuel cost | Prime SD fuel cost | Tour S fuel saving |
|---|---|---|---|
| 50,000 km | ₹1,31,195 1,457.7 kg CNG | ₹1,58,451 1,760.6 kg CNG | ₹27,255 |
| 1,00,000 km | ₹2,62,391 2,915.5 kg CNG | ₹3,16,901 3,521.1 kg CNG | ₹54,511 |
| 1,50,000 km | ₹3,93,586 4,373.2 kg CNG | ₹4,75,352 5,281.7 kg CNG | ₹81,766 |
| 2,00,000 km | ₹5,24,781 5,830.9 kg CNG | ₹6,33,803 7,042.3 kg CNG | ₹1,09,021 |
Calculation: distance ÷ manufacturer-claimed km/kg × your CNG price. Fuel-only comparison; excludes petrol used during starting/operation, maintenance, tyres, insurance, finance, downtime and other operating costs. Real-world mileage can materially change the result.
Beyond mileage: what matters on daily taxi duty
PRIME SD lists a rear AC vent plus front and rear power windows. Tour S lists a digital air conditioner plus front and rear power windows.
Both list 6 airbags. Tour S lists ABS with EBD and Brake Assist, while PRIME SD lists ABS with EBD, an 80 km/h speed-limiting function and VLTD with panic buttons.
Hyundai's PRIME SD product page states 3 years/1,00,000 km warranty and 3-year roadside assistance, and mentions an extended-warranty option up to 5 years/1,80,000 km. Because Hyundai's general extended-warranty terms also contain taxi/fleet exclusions, confirm PRIME-specific extended-warranty eligibility in writing before purchase.
We will not publish invented service costs
Hyundai currently advertises PRIME SD maintenance at 47 paise/km, but that is a manufacturer claim based on its stated maintenance assumptions—not a real-world all-in taxi maintenance bill. A proper ownership comparison should also include service, tyres, brakes, clutch, CNG-system work and high-mileage wear. Until we have sufficiently comparable verified rupee bills for both vehicles, we will keep actual maintenance costs unfilled.
Useful for comparison only when clearly labelled. It is not a substitute for an actual commercial-taxi service bill.
Use only when clearly labelled as city- and date-specific indicative pricing.
Best evidence for real commercial-vehicle maintenance cost when anonymised and documented.
Which one looks stronger for a taxi owner?
Tour S has the clear manufacturer-claimed CNG mileage advantage: 34.30 km/kg versus 28.40 km/kg. For a high-running taxi, that difference can become significant, so use the fuel calculator with your own monthly kilometres and local CNG price.
PRIME SD currently carries the lower manufacturer-published ex-showroom reference and adds taxi-duty features including a rear AC vent and VLTD with panic buttons. Its case should still be judged against local commercial setup cost and real-world fuel, service and downtime experience.
Tour S CNG vs PRIME SD CNG FAQ
Which car has better claimed CNG mileage?
Maruti Suzuki currently publishes 34.30 km/kg for Tour S CNG, while Hyundai publishes 28.40 km/kg for PRIME SD CNG. These are manufacturer-claimed figures, not guaranteed real-world taxi mileage.
Which car has the lower current ex-showroom reference price?
Hyundai PRIME SD is currently shown at ₹6,95,600 ex-showroom, while Maruti Suzuki Tour S CNG is shown at ₹7,09,800. Final commercial on-road cost can differ materially by state, insurance, permit, VLTD/GPS, dealer charges and discounts.
Does the cheaper ex-showroom car always cost less to own?
No. Taxi ownership cost also depends on fuel economy, monthly running, finance, maintenance, tyres, downtime, insurance, permits, resale and local statutory charges.
Are the Ranchi/Jharkhand figures nationwide prices?
No. The Jharkhand figures shown in the state-wise section are reference cases only. They should not be treated as nationwide on-road prices or guaranteed current quotations.